Question:
Do you believe that radiation coming from mobile phones can cause brain tumours?
Anamaria UK
2008-10-01 00:53:13 UTC
Recent research from Sweden indicates a connection between mobile phone usage and the formation of brain tumours (known as "gliomas") as well as benign tumours on the main nerve responsible for hearing. Cordless phones also posed a similar risk, according to this report. These gliomas tend to form on the side of the head where the user puts the phone when he is speaking. Do you think this a reality, or even more fear mongering?
Twelve answers:
John
2008-10-01 04:16:49 UTC
This is certainly a real and most serious concern and we'll be seeing more and more reports as time goes on, as the true effects start to materialise. The thing to remember is that mobile phones have only started being used extensively in the last 8 or so years. It will take time for any definitive effects to become apparent. (typically 10 - 20 years), therefore anyone who says that they are not harmfull is doing so without any real knowledge or understanding!



The fact is that radio frequency (RF) transmissions are DANGEROUS. As to how dangerous, well that all depends on the intensity and duration of exposure. No one really knows and those that say it is not a problem, have no evidence to substantiate that it is not, infact there is more evidence coming to light to say that it is a potentially real serious problem! Any possible adverse effects that these devices have on human tissue, should not be taken lightly! It is still early days and time will tell as it did for smoking, asbestos related products and countless of chemicals and herbacides, in the past.

The simple fact is that everyone should be aware that the longer you use the phone the greater the adverse affects are likely to be. There is no doubt whatsoever, and it is well documented that high levels of RF are DANGEROUS! Cell phones transmit at much lower energy levels, but their consistant and prolonged use may well have a cumalitive effect.



Although there is no proof to indicate that mobile phones can cause cancer, there is sufficient debate and more studies happening to cause doubt as to the relative safety. As a telecommunications engineer I am aware of the power density levels produced by mobile phones and the effect they can have on different people.

Mobile phones transmit using radio frequency radiation (RFR). Dependant on the network this can range between 800MHz and 2GHz. These are radio waves located within the electromagnetic spectrum. X-rays which are known to cause cancer through ionizing radiation are also within the electromagnetic spectrum, however, RFRs cannot cause cancer in the same way as x-rays because RFRs are non-ionizing.



However, high levels of RFRs can cause health effects through heating the human body (thermal effects), resulting in headaches and possibly other symptoms.



Whilst it cannot be shown at this point in time that the thermal effects from mobile phones are a health hazard there is a considerable body of scientific literature which describes the effects of RFR in biological systems that cannot be directly attributed to heating. These effects are referred to as non-thermal and have been demonstrated to cause alteration in animal behaviour, or changes in the functioning of cell membranes.



To limit the possible adverse effects mobile phones may have I would suggest that anyone concerned about their use should;



- Limit the prolonged use of mobiles to under a couple of minutes at a time.

- Use the phone in handsfree speaker mode.

- Avoid using the phone in a confined space (such as in the car or building) as this causes the phone to radiate at the higher power levels to get a signal out.



Personnaly I avoid using the phone as much as possible and if I need to use it I keep it under a few minutes or use it in hands free speaker phone mode.



If you want to read some more detailed neurological studies and reports then checkout the following links
anonymous
2008-10-01 08:25:53 UTC
Hello,



(ANS) The problem with the issue of mobile phones, radiation & the risks to health is that ALL the serious scientific studies & there have been quite a number over the last 10 years. ALL have ended with unclear or inconclusive findings.



**A number of studies show circumstantial evidence (weak evidence) for harm to health but no direct causal link can be proved. i.e. that mobile phone usage causes radiation damage to the human body.



**However, the scientific researchers ALL stated that mobile phone usage should be kept to the barest minimum for adults and that young children i.e. 16years or less should not use mobiles at all. In other words the scientists themselves advise a highly precautionary approach to mobile phone use due to the potential or unknown risks.



**"If any harm to health" is caused directly by mobile phones then a) I think we would be starting to see the health evidence already given that we have had mobile phones for 10 years now and b) the health effects might not become clearer for another 10years or so?



**All I know is that I read the story of a man who had been a BT engineer who was forced by his employer to spend pro longed periods on a mobile each working day. A number of years later he developed a large cancerous tumor precisely were he had held the phone to his head. He retired on grounds of ill health & tried to take BT to court for compensation (not sure what the out come of the case was) for the effects. He stated that he thought the tumor was directly related to the mobile phone usage over many many months. Enough said I think.



**On a personal level, on the few rare occations I have used a mobile phone I have never felt OK about the feeling it leaves you with. On one occation just using the phone gave me a headarche. Which has been enough to put me off using them at all. I'm NOT a mobile phone fan in fact quite the opposite I'd get rid of them if I could, I think they are extremely anti social much of the time.



Regards Ivan
anonymous
2008-10-01 08:08:21 UTC
Ye I think it can happen but it is so little you would have to be talking on the phone at least for 2.5 hours a day. When you are talking on a phone that is when it gives off the most radiation. so just dont talk a lot.
anonymous
2008-10-03 09:16:20 UTC
In recent times their has been an epidemic in brain tumours in children. Brain tumours are the highest forms of cancer in children. Their brains are not fully developed yet and having a mobile stuck totheire ear will have some effect even if they carry it on their body.
priya S
2008-10-03 06:54:45 UTC
visit the following url
livewire
2008-10-01 12:25:54 UTC
I just bought a head set for my phone and it clearly says on the package" using the head phone will reduce the harmful radiation". Also when you purchase a new phone read the manual. It says you must carry it in a proper pouch. Cell phones will strip the magnetic field of some credit cards so they can not be ruled out as harmless.All this said I am guessing you must really talk on the phone for a long time to get enough radiation for a brain tumor.
viswa.dr2009
2008-10-01 11:07:23 UTC
may be yes ...



to much of any thing is a danger and mobile phones are no exceptions .

wen ur computer emits radiation , mobiles too can .



u can do a google and c there are hundreds of pages supporting my veiw . use ur gadgets sesibly . do u knw using ear phons for an hour increases organisms in ur ears by 100 times
ukmolly
2008-10-01 10:17:43 UTC
The problem is, these tumours are so rare that, even if the risk is increased with mobile phone use, the sample of people with the disease is too small to be statistically conclusive. The study you refer to is too small to be relied on, and the researchers themselves state that the link is only a possible one, and that more research is required to be sure one way or the other.



I think it's an interesting piece of research, and it's possible that there is a link. But the way the newspapers have picked up this, rather than one of the many other, less 'sexy', pieces of research published every day, is definitely fear mongering in my opinion!
MC
2008-10-01 07:57:53 UTC
I think it's possible.....and i would not want to one of the ones who are going to prove it!
kookiboo
2008-10-01 08:04:57 UTC
If you put 4 mobile phones in a cross and put some pop corn kernels in the middle then ring all four mobiles they will pop the corn!!! so make what you will of that.
Clint Eastwood
2008-10-01 07:59:21 UTC
well looking up at stars gives you cancer

rubbing talking powder on your nose then eating mentos gives you a itchy nose.....
Amy T
2008-10-01 07:57:58 UTC
No.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...